top of page
HCL Review
nexus institue transparent.png
Catalyst Center Transparent.png
Adaptive Lab Transparent.png
Foundations of Leadership
DEIB
Purpose-Driven Workplace
Creating a Dynamic Organizational Culture
Strategic People Management Capstone

The Second Paycheck: Side Hustles, Moonlighting, and How Leaders Can Govern Multiple Jobholding Without Losing Trust

30 minutes ago
26 min read

Download the article here:


Listen to a review of this article:


Abstract: Holding more than one job has moved from the margins of working life toward its mainstream. G-P's 2026 World at Work Report, a survey of 7,100 executives and professionals in six countries, finds that 43% of employees already have a secondary income stream and 31% are considering one, while 79% of organizations maintain formal policies against secondary employment. U.S. federal data show multiple jobholding at 5.5% of employed people in September 2026, and Australia reports rates near historic highs. This article examines the drivers of multiple jobholding, from cost-of-living pressure to the search for autonomy, and its consequences for performance, wellbeing, confidentiality, and trust. Drawing on organizational research and documented cases across IT services, technology platforms, cybersecurity, public administration, and graduate medical education, it argues that blanket prohibitions are increasingly unenforceable, legally constrained, and counterproductive. It proposes evidence-based responses built on risk-based policy, safe disclosure, identity integrity, capacity management, and attention to the push factors that drive employees to seek a second paycheck.
 

For much of the twentieth century, a second job was something people did quietly and out of necessity: an evening shift at a restaurant, weekend work at a hardware store, a summer job for a teacher. Employers rarely asked about it, and employees rarely told. That arrangement is changing. Remote work has made it possible to hold two salaried roles from the same laptop. Digital platforms have turned skills into sellable services overnight. And cost-of-living pressures have made a second income feel less like ambition and more like insurance.

 

New data released this week put numbers to the shift. G-P's 2026 World at Work Report, based on a survey of 7,100 business leaders and professionals in the United States, United Kingdom, Australia, France, Germany, and Singapore, finds that 43% of employees have a secondary income stream and another 31% are considering one. At the same time, 79% of organizations report formal policies against secondary employment (G-P, 2026). The gap between those two numbers is the subject of this article. Either a very large share of the workforce is violating policy, or the policies themselves have lost touch with how people now work, or both.

 

The same report finds that 62% of employees are actively searching or likely to search for a new job within six months, up from 52% a year earlier, and that 28% have worked remotely from another country or state for more than 30 consecutive days without notifying HR (G-P, 2026). Taken together, these figures describe a workforce that is confident, mobile, and increasingly willing to operate outside the boundaries that employers draw on paper. Official statistics point in the same direction. In the United States, multiple jobholders made up 5.5% of employed people in September 2026, the latest Current Population Survey reading (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026). In Australia, the rate of multiple job-holding has remained between 6.4% and 6.7% since mid-2022, which the national statistics agency describes as an all-time high range (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2026).

 

The stakes for leaders are practical. Undisclosed second jobs can create conflicts of interest, leak confidential information, and, in the most extreme cases, become vehicles for fraud. Fatigue from long combined hours can compromise safety. Yet heavy-handed responses carry their own costs. Employees who fear punishment for disclosure will simply stop disclosing. Surveillance aimed at catching moonlighters can damage trust across the entire workforce. And in a growing number of jurisdictions, blanket bans on outside work are no longer legally enforceable.

 

Research suggests a more nuanced picture than the moral language that often surrounds the topic. Multiple jobholding can deplete workers, but it can also enrich them, building skills, confidence, and engagement that flow back into the primary job (Campion et al., 2020; Sessions et al., 2021). Whether it does one or the other depends heavily on why people take on second jobs and how organizations respond. This article examines the landscape, consequences, and evidence-based responses, with the aim of helping leaders move from prohibition toward governance.

 

The Multiple Jobholding Landscape

 

Defining Multiple Jobholding, Moonlighting, and Overemployment

Several overlapping terms are in use. Multiple jobholding is the broad term used by statisticians and researchers for working more than one job during the same period, whether as an employee, a self-employed person, or both (Campion et al., 2020). Moonlighting typically refers to holding a second job in addition to a primary full-time position, often outside regular hours; in some industries, notably Indian IT services, the term has come to imply secret work for a competitor. A side hustle usually describes self-directed income-generating work, such as freelancing, consulting, content creation, or a small business, undertaken alongside a primary job (Sessions et al., 2021). Hybrid entrepreneurship is the research term for running a business while remaining in wage employment, often as a stepping stone to full-time self-employment (Folta et al., 2010; Raffiee & Feng, 2014).

 

Overemployment describes holding two or more full-time salaried roles simultaneously, usually remotely, and usually without the knowledge of at least one employer. It differs from moonlighting in that the jobs overlap in time rather than occurring sequentially. Finally, secondary income is a broader category that includes any additional earnings outside a primary job, from rental income to gig work, and is the construct measured in the G-P survey.

 

These distinctions matter because the risks differ. A nurse who picks up weekend shifts at a different hospital, a software engineer who builds an app on weekends, a teacher who tutors in the evenings, and a remote employee who secretly works two full-time jobs during the same business hours represent very different situations. Treating them all as "moonlighting" obscures the policy questions that actually matter: whether the outside work creates a conflict of interest, threatens confidential information, compromises safety, or breaches an explicit commitment of time.

 

Prevalence, Drivers, and Distribution

Measured rates of multiple jobholding vary widely depending on definitions and sources. Official labor force surveys capture people who report more than one job in a reference week, and they tend to undercount informal and occasional work. In the United States, the Current Population Survey recorded multiple jobholders at 5.5% of the employed in September 2026, up from 5.2% in May (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2026). Australia's measure stood at 6.5% in December 2025, with notably higher rates among women (7.1%) than men (5.8%) and among workers aged 20 to 24 (10.5%) (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2026). Broader surveys that include any secondary income source, such as G-P's, produce much higher figures.


Multiple jobholding is concentrated in certain occupations and sectors. In Australia, the highest rates are found in agriculture, administrative and support services, and arts and recreation, and among community and personal service workers (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2026). In the United States, teachers stand out. Pew Research Center's analysis of federal education data found that 17% of full-time public school teachers worked a nonschool job during the 2020–21 school year and 16% did so over the summer, roughly three and a half times the rate among all U.S. workers aged 20 and older over the same period (Hatfield, 2025). Teachers with second jobs during the school year earned an average of about $6,090 from that work, and about half of public K–12 teachers surveyed in 2023 were dissatisfied with their pay.

 

Researchers distinguish between two broad families of motives. Push motives involve necessity: insufficient income or hours in the primary job, financial shocks, or job insecurity. Pull motives involve opportunity: the desire for variety, autonomy, skill development, meaning, or a path to entrepreneurship (Campion et al., 2020). The distinction is not merely academic. Campion and colleagues propose that push-driven multiple jobholding is more likely to deplete workers, while pull-driven multiple jobholding is more likely to enrich them. Many workers experience both at once, and the balance can shift over time.

 

Several forces are amplifying both kinds of motive. On the push side, cost-of-living pressures and stagnant real wages in many occupations encourage people to diversify income. Labor market precarity, including the rise of contract and platform work, has reduced the security that a single employer once provided (Kalleberg, 2009). On the pull side, digital platforms have lowered the barriers to selling skills, and the growth of remote and hybrid work has given many employees more control over their time. Generational expectations also play a role: younger workers report higher rates of multiple jobholding in Australia, and the G-P survey finds a workforce that is restless and willing to change employers (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2026; G-P, 2026).

 

Technology has also enabled a new and more contentious form of multiple jobholding. In fully remote roles, it is possible to hold two full-time positions with overlapping hours, relying on the difficulty of observing work directly. The G-P finding that 28% of employees have worked from another location for more than a month without telling HR illustrates how far actual practice can drift from what employers believe is happening (G-P, 2026). The same visibility gap that enables overemployment has been exploited by organized fraud, as later sections describe.

 

The distribution of multiple jobholding also reflects differences in bargaining power. Workers with scarce, portable skills, such as software engineers, designers, and data specialists, can often command premium rates for outside work and choose projects that build their reputation. Workers in lower-paid service roles more often combine jobs out of necessity, with less control over schedules and fewer protections in either role. Gender patterns, such as Australia's higher rate among women (Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2026), may reflect a greater prevalence of part-time primary jobs that need to be supplemented. These differences mean that a single organizational policy will land very differently on different parts of the workforce, a point that matters both for fairness and for the effectiveness of any response.

 

Organizational and Individual Consequences

 

Organizational Performance Impacts

The research on performance effects is more balanced than popular debate suggests. Campion et al. (2020), in an integrative review spanning management, economics, sociology, and health research, conclude that findings on whether multiple jobholding depletes or enriches workers are inconsistent, both across and within fields, and that outcomes depend on mechanisms and boundary conditions that have rarely been studied directly.

 

The most rigorous evidence on side hustles specifically comes from Sessions et al. (2021), who studied 337 full-time employees with side hustles using multiple surveys, a daily diary design, and coworker ratings of performance in the primary job. They found that side hustles generated feelings of empowerment, because workers controlled what, when, and where they worked. That empowerment produced positive emotions that spilled over into the full-time job, increasing persistence and cooperation with coworkers. Side hustles also produced a cost: on some days, employees' minds drifted to their side work, reducing attention. On balance, however, the positive effects outweighed the distraction, producing a net improvement in rated performance in the primary job. The effects were strongest when side hustles offered autonomy and when they were pursued for motives such as earning more, socializing, or variety.

 

Identity research adds a further layer. Caza et al. (2018) studied people who hold multiple work identities, such as an accountant who is also a musician, and found that over time many move from simply juggling roles toward integrating them, drawing on skills and perspectives from each. Research on hybrid entrepreneurship similarly suggests that starting a business while employed reduces the risk of entrepreneurial failure and can be a deliberate learning strategy (Folta et al., 2010; Raffiee & Feng, 2014). For employers, this suggests that some outside work functions as low-cost development, building capabilities that employees bring back to the primary role.

 

The risks to organizations are nonetheless real. The first is conflict of interest, particularly when employees work for competitors, clients, or suppliers. The second is confidentiality: employees with access to proprietary code, customer data, or strategic plans may, deliberately or carelessly, carry that information into another role. The third is time theft in its literal sense, where an employee who has committed to full-time hours is in fact working for another employer during those hours. The fourth is capacity: long combined hours can reduce performance, increase errors, and in safety-critical settings create risk to others.

 

The Indian IT services industry became the most visible battleground for these issues in 2022. Wipro's chairman, Rishad Premji, described secretly holding a second job as cheating and revealed that the company had terminated 300 employees found to be working simultaneously for competitors (The Register, 2022). Infosys sent employees an internal message titled "No Double Lives," warning that dual employment was not permitted and could lead to termination, and TCS's chief operating officer described moonlighting as an ethical issue that damages company culture (The Register, 2022). Yet within weeks, Infosys announced that employees could take up external gig work with the prior consent of their manager and HR business partner, provided it was done in personal time, did not involve competitors or clients, and did not affect performance (The News Minute, 2022). The industry's rapid movement from condemnation to conditional permission illustrates the tension between protecting legitimate interests and acknowledging how people now work.

 

Overemployment presents the sharpest performance and integrity risk. In October 2025, New York's Inspector General announced the arrest of a remote project coordinator in the state's Office of Information Technology Services who was alleged to have worked full-time for a contractor at a semiconductor manufacturer while on the clock for his state job from March 2022 to September 2025, resulting in a charge of grand larceny relating to about $50,000 in taxpayer funds (New York State Office of the Inspector General, 2025). The charge is an allegation, and the employee is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. In the startup world, the case of software engineer Soham Parekh drew widespread attention in July 2025 after Playground AI's chief executive publicly warned that Parekh had been working at several startups at the same time. Multiple companies, including Playground AI, Lindy, Antimetal, and Sync Labs, reported having let him go, and Parekh acknowledged holding multiple jobs simultaneously since 2022, citing financial pressure (Zeff, 2025).

 

Individual Wellbeing and Stakeholder Impacts

For workers, the consequences of multiple jobholding depend heavily on motive and conditions. Push-driven multiple jobholding, undertaken because one job does not pay enough, is associated with long hours, reduced recovery, and strain. Research using national U.S. survey data found that multiple jobholders had significantly higher rates of both work-related and non-work-related injuries than single jobholders (Marucci-Wellman et al., 2014), and related time-use research found that working multiple jobs was associated with longer working days and shorter sleep (Marucci-Wellman et al., 2016). Recovery research explains why: psychological detachment from work, relaxation, and control over leisure time are central to restoring energy, and these experiences are precisely what long combined hours squeeze out (Sonnentag & Fritz, 2007).

 

Pull-driven multiple jobholding can have the opposite effect. Sessions et al. (2021) found that the autonomy of side hustles was energizing, and Caza et al. (2018) found that people who integrate multiple work identities can experience a stronger sense of authenticity. Boundary theory helps explain the difference: workers who can manage transitions between roles on their own terms experience less conflict than those whose roles collide (Ashforth et al., 2000). The same second job can be energizing for one person and exhausting for another, depending on whether it is chosen, controllable, and compatible with the first.

 

Secrecy itself is a source of strain. Employees who hold undisclosed second jobs must manage the risk of discovery, which adds cognitive load and anxiety. When organizations ban outside work outright, they effectively force that secrecy onto employees who would otherwise disclose. Wipro's own chairman acknowledged this dynamic, arguing that employees should be open about after-hours activities so that employer and employee can decide together whether an arrangement works (The Register, 2022).

 

It is also worth recognizing that, from the worker's perspective, a second income can be a rational response to risk. When layoffs, restructuring, and automation make any single job feel less secure, diversifying income is a form of self-insurance, much as investors diversify a portfolio (Kalleberg, 2009). Leaders who interpret outside work purely as a loyalty problem may miss the signal it sends about how secure employees feel in their primary role.

 

Other stakeholders are affected as well. Clients of professional services firms rely on the attention and confidentiality of the staff they pay for. Patients rely on the alertness of clinicians, which is why graduate medical education regulators place explicit limits on resident moonlighting. Coworkers bear the consequences when a colleague's divided attention leads to missed deadlines or errors. Taxpayers bear the cost when public employees are paid for time they spend working elsewhere, as in the New York case.

 

Finally, multiple jobholding affects the psychological contract, the set of beliefs each party holds about what they owe the other (Rousseau, 1989). Employers that expect exclusive commitment while offering limited security or pay growth may find that employees no longer share those expectations. When employees discover that colleagues have been fired for outside work they considered legitimate, or when employers discover undisclosed second jobs, trust erodes on both sides. Trust research shows that perceptions of ability, benevolence, and integrity underpin willingness to be vulnerable to another party (Mayer et al., 1995); multiple jobholding tests all three, from the employer's view of the employee's integrity to the employee's view of the employer's benevolence.

 

Evidence-Based Organizational Responses


The evidence suggests five responses that help organizations protect legitimate interests without driving outside work underground. Table 1 summarizes them.


Table 1. Evidence-based responses to multiple jobholding.

Response

Evidence Base

Key Practices

Illustrative Examples

Replace blanket bans with risk-based policy

EU transparent working conditions law; multiple jobholding research

Permit by default; restrict on objective grounds; tiered approval for higher-risk work

Swiggy; Infosys; Netherlands implementation of EU Directive

Make disclosure safe and simple

Psychological contract and trust research

Simple declaration process; no-penalty disclosure; periodic refresh; consistent decisions

Wipro (disclosure principle); Infosys (manager and HR consent)

Protect confidentiality and identity integrity

Fraud cases; remote hiring security incidents

Identity verification; access controls; conflict-of-interest declarations; cross-functional HR–security coordination

KnowBe4; U.S. Justice Department laptop-farm actions; New York State ITS; Playground AI and Lindy

Manage capacity in safety-critical roles

Injury and sleep research; recovery research

Hours limits that count all work; fitness-for-duty standards; approval for high-risk roles

ACGME requirements; UCLA graduate medical education

Address the push factors

Push–pull motivation research; side-hustle empowerment research

Pay adequacy reviews; internal gigs and stretch assignments; flexibility and autonomy in the primary job

Public school teachers; Infosys internal gig policy

 

Replace Blanket Bans With Risk-Based Policy

The first response is to move from prohibition to risk-based governance. Blanket bans have three weaknesses. They are hard to enforce, as the gap between the 79% of organizations with formal policies against secondary employment and the 43% of employees with secondary income suggests (G-P, 2026). They are increasingly constrained by law. And they suppress disclosure, leaving organizations less informed about genuine risks.

 

The legal shift is clearest in Europe. Article 9 of the European Union's Directive on transparent and predictable working conditions requires member states to ensure that employers do not prohibit workers from taking up employment with other employers outside the work schedule, or subject them to adverse treatment for doing so. Member states may allow restrictions on objective grounds, such as health and safety, protection of business confidentiality, the integrity of the public service, or the avoidance of conflicts of interest (Directive (EU) 2019/1152, 2019). The Netherlands implemented this principle in its civil code from August 2022: a clause prohibiting or restricting work for others outside working hours is void unless justified by an objective ground, and general appeals to business interests are not sufficient (Law & More, n.d.).

 

Effective approaches:

 

  • Permit by default: State clearly that outside work in personal time is allowed unless it falls into defined risk categories.

  • Define objective grounds: Specify the grounds for restriction, such as direct competition, confidential information, safety-critical fatigue, regulatory independence, or public integrity.

  • Tier the process: Allow low-risk activities with simple notice, and reserve formal approval for activities that touch competitors, clients, suppliers, or safety-critical roles.

  • Separate overlap from outside work: Distinguish clearly between outside work in personal time and undisclosed work for another employer during committed working hours.

  • Review regularly: Revisit policy as roles, technologies, and legal requirements change.

 

A useful way to operationalize risk-based policy is to assess outside work along two dimensions. The first is conflict and confidentiality risk: whether the outside work involves competitors, clients, suppliers, or information the employee holds by virtue of the primary role. The second is capacity and safety risk: whether the combined hours or timing of the work could impair fitness for duty, particularly in safety-critical roles, or overlap with committed working hours. Most outside work, such as tutoring, creative projects, small businesses, or occasional freelancing in unrelated fields, sits low on both dimensions and can be permitted with simple notice. Work that is high on one dimension calls for approval with conditions tailored to that risk, such as an information firewall or an hours cap. Work that is high on both, or that involves undisclosed overlap with committed hours, is where restriction is most clearly justified.

 

Swiggy, the Indian food delivery platform, introduced what it described as an industry-first moonlighting policy in August 2022. The policy allows employees to take on external projects, paid or unpaid, outside office hours or on weekends, provided the work does not affect productivity, does not create a conflict of interest with Swiggy's business, and goes through additional approval where conflict risks are higher (Pathak, 2022). Swiggy's head of HR framed the policy as part of the future of work, and other Indian employers, including the online matrimonial services firm Matrimony.com, signaled acceptance of outside work that did not involve competitors or confidential information (HRKatha, 2022).

 

Infosys offers an example of an organization that moved from prohibition to conditional permission. After warning employees that dual employment was not allowed, the company announced weeks later that employees could take up external gig work with prior consent from their manager and HR business partner, provided the work was in personal time, did not involve competitors or clients, and did not affect performance (The News Minute, 2022). The company retained its contractual prohibition on dual employment and conflicts of interest, effectively separating legitimate side work from the kind of moonlighting it considered a breach.

 

The pitfall is replacing one blanket rule with another. A policy that permits everything is as poorly calibrated as one that forbids everything. Risk-based governance requires clear categories and consistent judgments, or it collapses into case-by-case discretion that employees experience as arbitrary.

 

Make Disclosure Safe and Simple

The second response focuses on information. An organization cannot manage risks it does not know about, and employees will not disclose if disclosure invites punishment. Psychological contract research shows that perceived breaches of expectations, in either direction, damage trust (Rousseau, 1989). Trust research shows that willingness to be vulnerable depends on perceptions of the other party's integrity and benevolence (Mayer et al., 1995). A disclosure process that is simple, predictable, and fair signals both.

 

Effective approaches:

 

  • Keep it simple: Use a short declaration form that captures the nature of the outside work, approximate hours, and any relationship to competitors, clients, or suppliers.

  • Separate disclosure from discipline: Make clear that disclosure of permitted activity carries no penalty and will not affect performance evaluations or promotion.

  • Refresh periodically: Ask employees to confirm or update declarations annually, alongside conflict-of-interest attestations.

  • Decide consistently: Use a small panel or documented criteria so that similar requests receive similar answers.

  • Protect privacy: Limit access to declarations to those who need it and avoid collecting more information than necessary.

 

Even at the height of its moonlighting controversy, Wipro's chairman articulated the disclosure principle: employees should be transparent about after-hours activities, so that employer and employee can have an open conversation and decide together whether an arrangement works (The Register, 2022). The organizations that moved toward conditional permission, including Infosys and Swiggy, built that principle into formal processes requiring manager and HR consent for outside work (Pathak, 2022; The News Minute, 2022).

 

Managers play a pivotal role in making disclosure work. Many employees will first mention outside work informally, in a one-to-one conversation or a development discussion, rather than through a form. Managers who respond with curiosity rather than suspicion, asking what the employee is learning, how the work fits around their commitments, and whether any conflicts might arise, turn a potential compliance issue into a development conversation. Organizations can support this by giving managers short guidance on the questions to ask, the categories that require escalation, and the commitments the organization makes to employees who disclose. Consistency across managers is essential: if one team leader welcomes outside work and another treats it as disloyalty, employees will learn that the real policy depends on who they work for.

 

The pitfall is collecting declarations and then using them punitively. If employees who disclose are passed over for promotion or quietly questioned about their commitment, word spreads quickly, and disclosure rates fall. A disclosure process is only as credible as the organization's track record of honoring it.

 

Protect Confidentiality and Identity Integrity

The third response addresses the narrower but more serious risks: conflicts of interest, information leakage, and outright fraud. Remote work has created new vulnerabilities, particularly in hiring and identity verification, that go well beyond conventional moonlighting.

 

The most dramatic illustration is the use of fraudulent remote IT workers by North Korea. In July 2024, the cybersecurity training company KnowBe4 disclosed that it had hired a remote software engineer who passed background checks, reference checks, and four video interviews, but who was in fact using a stolen U.S. identity and an AI-enhanced photograph. The company's security operations center detected suspicious activity when malware was loaded onto the worker's company laptop, contained the device, and later concluded with the FBI and Mandiant that the worker was operating from North Korea; the company reported that no data was lost or exfiltrated (CyberScoop, 2024). In June 2025, the U.S. Justice Department announced coordinated actions against similar schemes, including searches of 29 known or suspected laptop farms across 16 states, and stated that the workers had obtained employment with more than 100 U.S. companies (CyberScoop, 2025).

 

These cases are not typical moonlighting, but they share a feature with overemployment: they exploit the gap between what employers can observe and what workers are actually doing. The New York State case and the Parekh case, described earlier, illustrate the ordinary end of the same spectrum, in which a remote worker's commitments to multiple employers went undetected for an extended period (New York State Office of the Inspector General, 2025; Zeff, 2025).

 

Effective approaches:

 

  • Verify identity rigorously: Strengthen identity validation before start dates for remote roles, including document checks and in-person or verified video steps where feasible.

  • Coordinate HR and security: Create shared processes between HR, IT, and security teams for onboarding, device management, and red-flag escalation.

  • Apply least-privilege access: Limit access to sensitive systems and data to what each role requires, and review access regularly.

  • Declare conflicts: Require conflict-of-interest declarations for roles with access to competitors, clients, or sensitive information.

  • Focus monitoring on risk: Use targeted security monitoring of systems and data rather than broad productivity surveillance of individuals.

 

KnowBe4's response is instructive. Its leaders emphasized weaknesses in hiring and background-check processes, the need for continuous security monitoring, and better coordination among HR, IT, and security teams, and the company strengthened identity validation before start dates and trained hiring staff on red flags (CyberScoop, 2024). Notably, the company's existing security controls, focused on systems and data rather than on individual productivity, were what detected the threat.

 

The pitfall is responding to rare fraud cases with workforce-wide surveillance. Meta-analytic evidence shows that electronic performance monitoring is not associated with improved performance and is associated with higher stress and lower job satisfaction (Ravid et al., 2023). Monitoring designed to catch moonlighters will burden the honest majority, damage trust, and may simply push determined bad actors toward better evasion.

 

Manage Capacity in Safety-Critical Roles

The fourth response addresses fatigue and safety. In most roles, the main risk of outside work is reduced performance. In safety-critical roles, such as medicine, transportation, energy, and manufacturing, the risk extends to others. Research linking multiple jobholding to higher injury rates and shorter sleep (Marucci-Wellman et al., 2014, 2016) and research on the importance of recovery (Sonnentag & Fritz, 2007) support stronger controls in these settings.

 

Effective approaches:

 

  • Count all hours: Where hours limits exist for safety reasons, count hours worked in all jobs, not only the primary one.

  • Set fitness-for-duty standards: Define expectations for rest and alertness before safety-critical shifts.

  • Require approval for high-risk roles: Apply a formal approval process to outside work by staff in safety-critical positions.

  • Monitor for warning signs: Train supervisors to recognize signs of fatigue and to raise concerns supportively.

  • Restrict where necessary: Use the objective grounds that law and evidence support, and document the rationale.

 

Graduate medical education provides a well-established model. Under the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education's common program requirements, time spent moonlighting counts toward residents' 80-hour weekly limit, first-year residents may not moonlight, and moonlighting must not interfere with educational goals, fitness for work, or patient safety (Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, 2023). Institutions implement these requirements through local policies. At UCLA, for example, residents require written or electronic approval from their program director before moonlighting, and program directors monitor resident performance for adverse effects (David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, n.d.).

 

This model works because it is specific, evidence-based, and applied consistently. It does not prohibit outside work; it governs it in proportion to the risk it creates for patients. The pitfall is applying safety-critical controls to roles where they are not justified. Requiring every office worker to log outside hours, for example, imposes administrative burden and signals distrust without meaningfully reducing risk.

 

Address the Push Factors

The fifth response looks upstream. Many employees take second jobs because their primary job does not meet their financial or developmental needs. Campion et al. (2020) distinguish push from pull motives and suggest that push-driven multiple jobholding is more likely to deplete workers. Organizations that reduce the push, through adequate pay and growth opportunities, are likely to see less depleting outside work and more engaged employees.

 

Effective approaches:

 

  • Review pay adequacy: Benchmark pay for roles where multiple jobholding is common, and examine whether base pay supports a reasonable standard of living.

  • Offer internal opportunities: Create internal gig marketplaces, stretch assignments, and project rotations that satisfy the desire for variety and growth.

  • Build autonomy into the primary job: Give employees more control over how and when they work, which the side-hustle evidence suggests is a key source of empowerment (Sessions et al., 2021).

  • Support entrepreneurial interests: Consider sabbaticals, innovation time, or intrapreneurship programs for employees with entrepreneurial ambitions.

  • Listen to motives: Use disclosure processes and surveys to understand why employees take on outside work, and respond to patterns.

 

Public school teachers illustrate the push side clearly. Pew Research Center's analysis found that 17% of full-time public school teachers worked a nonschool job during the school year, far above the rate among all workers, and that about half were dissatisfied with their pay (Hatfield, 2025). School systems that want teachers' full energy in the classroom have a direct interest in pay adequacy. Infosys's decision to permit approved gig work can be read in part as an acknowledgment of the pull side: skilled technology workers want variety and the chance to apply their skills in new contexts, and internal or approved channels for that desire are more productive than prohibition (The News Minute, 2022).

 

The pitfall is assuming that all outside work signals disengagement. The side-hustle research suggests that the autonomy and mastery people find in outside work can enrich their primary job (Sessions et al., 2021). Leaders who treat every second job as disloyalty may drive away precisely the curious, entrepreneurial employees they most want to keep.

 

Building Long-Term Workforce Trust and Flexibility

 

Outcome-Based Performance Management

Concerns about multiple jobholding are often concerns about whether work is getting done. Organizations with clear expectations, measurable outcomes, and regular conversations about performance are better placed to address that concern directly than organizations that rely on presence or activity as proxies. When performance is defined by outcomes, a manager can address a decline in performance regardless of its cause, whether a second job, a family crisis, or simple disengagement. This reduces the need to police outside activities and focuses attention on what matters. It also makes the distinction between legitimate outside work and time theft clearer: an employee who meets commitments and keeps confidences is fulfilling the employment relationship, while one who is absent during committed hours is not.

 

Outcome-based management does not mean abandoning expectations about availability. Roles that require real-time responsiveness, coverage of shifts, or collaboration across time zones should make those requirements explicit. The aim is to make expectations transparent enough that both parties can tell whether they are being met, rather than relying on the assumption of exclusive attention.

 

Outcome-based management also improves the quality of conversations about capacity. When an employee's performance dips, a manager who focuses on outcomes can ask what has changed and what support would help, without presuming the cause. In some cases the answer will be outside work that has grown beyond what the employee can sustain, and the conversation can turn to adjusting one commitment or the other. In others, it will be something unrelated. Either way, the organization learns more from a supportive conversation than from investigation, and the employee is more likely to be candid about the trade-offs they are making.

 

Trust-Based Governance

The second pillar is governance built on trust rather than suspicion. Mayer et al. (1995) show that trust rests on perceptions of ability, benevolence, and integrity, and that it grows when parties demonstrate those qualities over time. Organizations can build trust by being transparent about their policies and the reasons for them, applying them consistently, and avoiding surveillance that signals distrust of the whole workforce. Monitoring should be targeted at genuine risks, such as access to sensitive systems, rather than at individual productivity (Ravid et al., 2023). In turn, employees who are trusted are more likely to disclose, to raise conflicts, and to honor their commitments.

 

Trust-based governance also requires accountability when trust is breached. The New York State and Wipro cases show that serious breaches, such as being paid for time spent working for another employer or secretly working for competitors, warrant firm responses (New York State Office of the Inspector General, 2025; The Register, 2022). Proportionality and consistency are what distinguish trust-based governance from permissiveness.

 

Governance should also be proportionate to role. Senior leaders, staff in regulated functions, and employees with access to highly sensitive information may reasonably be held to stricter standards of disclosure and approval than staff whose work carries little conflict or confidentiality risk. Public sector organizations have particular obligations to protect the integrity of public service, which the European framework explicitly recognizes as a legitimate ground for restriction (Directive (EU) 2019/1152, 2019). Making these distinctions explicit, rather than applying the strictest standard to everyone, helps employees see the policy as reasoned rather than reflexive.

 

Portfolio Careers and the Extended Workforce

The third pillar recognizes that careers are becoming more varied. Many workers will combine employment, freelancing, entrepreneurship, and caregiving over their working lives, sometimes simultaneously. Organizations that accept this reality can turn it into an advantage. Alumni networks, flexible return paths, internal marketplaces, and partnerships with former employees who have built businesses all extend an organization's access to talent. Research on hybrid entrepreneurship suggests that employees who test ventures while employed reduce their risk of failure (Raffiee & Feng, 2014), and some of those ventures may become suppliers, partners, or acquisitions. A workforce strategy that sees outside work as part of the talent ecosystem, rather than only as a threat, is better aligned with how many people now build careers.

 

Organizations can also learn from the outside work their employees do. Disclosure processes, if well designed, reveal what skills employees are developing, what kinds of work they find energizing, and where the primary job may be falling short. Patterns in that information can inform job design, learning investments, and internal mobility. An organization that notices many of its analysts building data products on weekends, for example, might ask whether it is giving those employees enough room to do similar work internally. In this way, the second paycheck becomes a source of insight into the first.

 

Conclusion

The data released this week confirm that a second paycheck has become a normal feature of working life for a large share of the workforce, even as most organizations retain policies that formally prohibit it. That gap is unsustainable. Blanket bans are difficult to enforce, increasingly constrained by law, and corrosive to the honest disclosure that organizations need to manage genuine risks. At the same time, the risks are real: conflicts of interest, confidentiality breaches, fatigue in safety-critical roles, and, at the extreme, fraud that exploits the blind spots of remote work.

 

The research points toward a middle path. Multiple jobholding can deplete or enrich, and which it does depends largely on why people take on outside work and how organizations respond. Leaders who replace prohibition with risk-based policy, make disclosure safe, protect confidentiality and identity integrity, manage capacity where safety demands it, and address the push factors that drive people to seek a second paycheck will be better placed to protect their interests and to retain the trust of their workforce.

 

Practical takeaways for leaders:

 

  • Audit your policy: Check whether your secondary employment policy reflects how people work now and complies with applicable law.

  • Permit by default, restrict by reason: Allow outside work in personal time, and restrict it only on clearly defined objective grounds.

  • Make disclosure easy and safe: Use a simple process, decide consistently, and never punish permitted activity that has been disclosed.

  • Separate side work from time theft: Distinguish clearly between outside work in personal time and undisclosed work for another employer during committed hours.

  • Strengthen identity and access controls: Verify identity for remote hires and coordinate HR, IT, and security, rather than surveilling everyone.

  • Govern fatigue where it matters: Count all hours and require approval in safety-critical roles.

  • Reduce the push: Review pay adequacy and create internal outlets for variety and growth.

 

Research Infographic




References


  1. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. (2023). ACGME common program requirements (residency). Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education.

  2. Ashforth, B. E., Kreiner, G. E., & Fugate, M. (2000). All in a day's work: Boundaries and micro role transitions. Academy of Management Review, 25(3), 472–491.

  3. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2026, March 13). Multiple job-holders, December 2025. Australian Bureau of Statistics.

  4. Campion, E. D., Caza, B. B., & Moss, S. E. (2020). Multiple jobholding: An integrative systematic review and future research agenda. Journal of Management, 46(1), 165–191.

  5. Caza, B. B., Moss, S., & Vough, H. (2018). From synchronizing to harmonizing: The process of authenticating multiple work identities. Administrative Science Quarterly, 63(4), 703–745.

  6. CyberScoop. (2024, July 24). Cyber firm KnowBe4 hired a fake IT worker from North Korea. CyberScoop.

  7. CyberScoop. (2025, June 30). Arrest, seizures target North Korean IT worker schemes. CyberScoop.

  8. David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA. (n.d.). UCLA GME moonlighting policy. University of California, Los Angeles.

  9. Directive (EU) 2019/1152 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2019 on transparent and predictable working conditions in the European Union. (2019). Official Journal of the European Union, L 186, 105–121.

  10. Folta, T. B., Delmar, F., & Wennberg, K. (2010). Hybrid entrepreneurship. Management Science, 56(2), 253–269.

  11. G-P. (2026, October 21). G-P's 2026 World at Work Report reveals a confident, but restless, global workforce [Press release]. PR Newswire.

  12. Hatfield, J. (2025, July 23). About 1 in 6 U.S. teachers work second jobs. Pew Research Center.

  13. HRKatha. (2022, August 24). The industry is divided on the idea of moonlighting. HRKatha.

  14. Kalleberg, A. L. (2009). Precarious work, insecure workers: Employment relations in transition. American Sociological Review, 74(1), 1–22.

  15. Law & More. (n.d.). Ancillary activities: What can and cannot an employer prohibit? Law & More.

  16. Marucci-Wellman, H. R., Lombardi, D. A., & Willetts, J. L. (2016). Working multiple jobs over a day or a week: Short-term effects on sleep duration. Chronobiology International, 33(6), 630–649.

  17. Marucci-Wellman, H. R., Willetts, J. L., Lin, T.-C., Brennan, M. J., & Verma, S. K. (2014). Work in multiple jobs and the risk of injury in the US working population. American Journal of Public Health, 104(1), 134–142.

  18. Mayer, R. C., Davis, J. H., & Schoorman, F. D. (1995). An integrative model of organizational trust. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 709–734.

  19. New York State Office of the Inspector General. (2025, October 16). Remote IT employee worked for state and GlobalFoundries at same time [Press release]. New York State Office of the Inspector General.

  20. Pathak, S. (2022, August 3). Swiggy launches moonlighting policy for its employees. Entrackr.

  21. Raffiee, J., & Feng, J. (2014). Should I quit my day job? A hybrid path to entrepreneurship. Academy of Management Journal, 57(4), 936–963.

  22. Ravid, D. M., White, J. C., Tomczak, D. L., Miles, A. F., & Behrend, T. S. (2023). A meta-analysis of the effects of electronic performance monitoring on work outcomes. Personnel Psychology, 76(1), 5–40.

  23. Rousseau, D. M. (1989). Psychological and implied contracts in organizations. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 2(2), 121–139.

  24. Sessions, H., Nahrgang, J. D., Vaulont, M. J., Williams, R., & Bartels, A. L. (2021). Do the hustle! Empowerment from side-hustles and its effects on full-time work performance. Academy of Management Journal, 64(1), 235–264.

  25. Sonnentag, S., & Fritz, C. (2007). The Recovery Experience Questionnaire: Development and validation of a measure for assessing recuperation and unwinding from work. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12(3), 204–221.

  26. The News Minute. (2022, October 21). Infosys allows employees to take up external gig work, with conditions. The News Minute.

  27. The Register. (2022, September 22). Wipro fires 300 for moonlighting. The Register.

  28. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2026). Multiple jobholders as a percent of employed [Data series LNS12026620]. Retrieved from Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, FRED.

  29. Zeff, M. (2025, July 3). Who is Soham Parekh, the serial moonlighter Silicon Valley startups can't stop hiring? TechCrunch.

Jonathan H. Westover, PhD, Chief Research Officer (Nexus Institute for Work and AI); Co-Founder & Chief Workforce and Learning Officer (Future State University); Founder & CEO (Human Capital Innovations); Professor of Organizational Leadership & Change (UVU). Read Jonathan Westover's executive profile here.

Suggested Citation: Westover, J. H. (2026). The Second Paycheck: Side Hustles, Moonlighting, and How Leaders Can Govern Multiple Jobholding Without Losing Trust. Human Capital Leadership Review, 40(4). doi.org/10.70175/hclreview.2020.40.4.7



Human Capital Leadership Review

eISSN 2693-9452 (online)

future of work collective transparent.png
Renaissance Project transparent.png

Subscription Form

HCI Academy Logo
Effective Teams in the Workplace
Employee Well being
Fostering Change Agility
Servant Leadership
Strategic Organizational Leadership Capstone
bottom of page