The Art & Science of Trust

Jonathan H. Westover, PhD
2 days ago
6 min read

Listen to this article:

Abstract: Trust is a fundamental component of successful organizations, impacting employee motivation, collaboration, and performance. This article examines both the scientific research behind trust-building and the practical leadership approaches needed to cultivate it. The authors present trust as both an art and science, requiring emotional intelligence alongside strategic implementation. The paper explores how trust develops through demonstrated competence, character integrity, effective communication, and industry-specific applications in healthcare and technology. Special attention is given to trust-building during crisis situations, where transparency and compassionate leadership become critical. By balancing research insights with actionable leadership practices, the article provides a comprehensive framework for understanding and strengthening organizational trust as a strategic advantage in today's complex business environment.

Trust is one of the most essential elements in any successful organization. It impacts employee motivation, collaboration, and overall performance. Yet trust can be fragile and must be continuously built and maintained through both art and science. This essay will explore the research behind what builds trust and practical steps leaders can take to strengthen trust within their own organizations.

Trust does not develop overnight. It is the cumulative result of consistent, competent, and caring leadership over time. While science provides guidelines, trust ultimately remains an art that requires emotional intelligence, mindfulness, and care on the part of leaders. Today we will balance both perspectives by first outlining the research foundation for what breeds trust, followed by specific, industry-applicable actions leaders can take to cultivate an atmosphere of trust.

Building Trust Through Competence

A foundation of trust begins with competence. People must have confidence in a leader's ability and expertise for trust to form. Research has identified several competence-based factors that build initial trust:

Technical skills: A leader needs relevant job skills, knowledge, and qualifications for the role. Lack of competence raises doubts.
Vision and direction: People want leaders who have a clear vision and strategy for the organization's future and can articulate how individual contributions fit into achieving that vision.
Follow-through: Trust increases when leaders do what they say they will do and deliver promised results. Consistency between words and actions is important.
Judgment and decision making: Leaders must demonstrate good judgment, make rational decisions based on logic and facts rather than bias or personal interests, and take responsibility for mistakes.

Practically, leaders can develop competence-based trust by maintaining high standards of professionalism, continuously upgrading skills through training, clearly communicating strategic priorities and how work aligns with achieving goals, and following through diligently on commitments. They should also be transparent and own decisions, both good and bad.

Building Trust Through Character

While competence is table stakes, deeper trust stems from a leader's character - their integrity, motives, and authentic caring for people. Research shows character-based factors like these nurture high-trust relationships:

Integrity: Aligning words with actions as mentioned, but also being honest, keeping promises, admitting faults.
Consistency: Behavior aligned with expressed values and priorities over the long-run builds predictability which fosters trust.
Loyalty: Trust increases when leaders publicly support and defend direct reports even during difficulties and do not undermine people behind their backs.
Motivation: People must believe a leader cares primarily about serving others rather than just personal interests like status and compensation. Motives should be evident.
Authenticity: Trust flourishes when people experience a leader's humanity through empathy, humor, willingness to admit vulnerabilities, asking for input, and showing care beyond just work topics.

Practically, leaders cultivate character-based trust by modeling high integrity even in small matters, walking the talk of values daily, showing public and persistent loyalty to employees, letting caring motivation versus self-interest shine through, and bringing their authentic humanity into interactions routinely. Leaders must allow themselves to be human and humbly earn trust over the long-run.

Building Trust in Healthcare

In the complex, stressful healthcare industry specifically, trust is crucial yet challenging to earn due to high pressure, regulated compliance, patient privacy concerns, and the serious consequences of mistakes for well-being. However, past scandals also show how swiftly trust can evaporate without proper culture-building. Some best practices for healthcare leaders include:

Prioritizing patient care and safety above all else. Uphold strict quality and compliance standards transparently. React swiftly and humanely to any incidents.
Promoting psychological safety. Encourage employees to speak up about concerns without fear so issues surface before becoming severe problems. Mediate conflicts quickly.
Valuing frontline input. Solicit clinician and staff feedback regarding operations and strategic plans. Involve direct care givers in decision-making.
Being visible and approachable. Round regularly, know employee names, maintain an open-door policy to understand realities on the ground level.
Recognizing contributions genuinely. Publicly thank and acknowledge staff at all levels for their service and sacrifices to build strong morale and loyalty.

By vigilantly focusing on competence and high integrity in healthcare delivery paired with compassionate culture-building, leadership lays a foundation of trust that allows doctors, nurses and support staff to optimally serve patients through teamwork and transparency.

Building Trust Through Communication

Once a base level of trust emerges due to competence and character, communication emerges as another crucial trust-nurturing factor. Leaders who effectively share information help foster understanding and connectedness. Research indicates communication that builds trust includes:

Sharing context: Explaining realities like financial constraints, regulatory issues, and competitive risks provides understanding of constraints and decisions.
Listening: Actively listening to concerns and challenges without defensiveness and then providing candid yet constructive feedback fosters an open dialog.
Broadcasting wins: Regularly communicating accomplishments, recognition of others' contributions, and celebrating wins together inspires shared pride and cohesion.
Advertising values: Repeatedly and consistently communicating core organizational values trains people on priorities and guides decision-making with transparency.

In practice, leaders build trust through communication by holding regular open forums for questions, circulating memos on operational realities and decisions promptly, conducting routine performance discussions with candor and care, and utilizing company values as a decision-making framework discussed publicly. Frequent two-way communication nourishes trusting relationships in today's information-driven world.

Building Trust in Technology

The technology industry presents unique trust challenges due to its complexity, rapid changes, and impacts on sensitive data and infrastructure. However, transparent communication and strong culture-building can still foster trust. Trust-building strategies for tech leadership include:

Prioritizing security and integrity. Make cybersecurity the top priority through investments, audits, patching, training, and response plans discussed openly.
Explaining innovations carefully. Clearly articulate new products, services risks/benefits with consumer education to build understanding and alleviate fears of unintended consequences.
Valuing customer feedback. Solicit input on user experiences and pain points to continually enhance the customer experience and catch potential issues early.
Enforcing accountability. Take responsibility for mistakes, apply lessons learned transparently, and apply consequences for policy violations to maintain high standards of conduct.

By combining technical competence, ethical transparency in communication, and a culture where the customer and security come before all else, leaders in technology can build the public, client, and employee trust necessary to drive innovation responsibly into the future.

Building Trust Through Crisis

While the importance of trust is elevated during periods of uncertainty, leaders also have opportunity during crises to strengthen trust through decisive yet compassionate crisis leadership. Research finds trust grows through crises when:

Providing timely, honest updates: Disclosing knowns and unknowns regularly reduces panic, shows transparency even during difficulties.
Demonstrating control: Outlining response plans and dedicating resources calms fears leadership has situation under control.
Activating teams proactively: Mobilizing task forces and clearly delineating roles maintains functionality and productivity during confusion.
Making care a priority: Protecting health, safety, jobs to extent possible through sacrifices elevates perceived concern for stakeholders over just survival of the organization.

During the Covid-19 pandemic, many health systems reinforced trust through decisive triaging of supplies, hospital capacity, and staffing needs while also implementing hardship funds, daily video updates, and care packages for employees’ families. Technology firms boosted trust by transitioning staff successfully to remote work and donating tech for medical and education needs. Decisive yet compassionate crisis leadership ultimately strengthens the trust that allows organizations to persevere through future difficulties.

Conclusion

While research provides guidelines, trust remains an art that leaders must continually nurture through competence, character, communication, and compassion—especially during crises. In today’s volatile world, trust has never been more critical or fragile for driving performance and innovation. Leaders who make building trust a daily priority through authentic actions large and small will produce the stable, cohesive cultures that thrive in a VUCA world. While challenging to quantify, a high-trust organizational climate rewards leaders long-term with engaged, committed talent and sustainable success. To lead is to serve and earn trust—the ultimate soft skill and strategic differentiator for any enduring organization.

References

Dirks, K. T., & Ferrin, D. L. (2002). Trust in leadership: Meta-analytic findings and implications for research and practice. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87(4), 611–628.
Mishra, A. K., & Mishra, K. E. (2013). The research on trust in leadership: The need for context. Journal of Trust Research, 3(1), 59-69.
Costa, A. C., Roe, R. A., & Taillieu, T. (2001). Trust within teams: The relation with performance effectiveness. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 10(3), 225–244.
Cullen, K., Edwards, B., Casper, W., & Gue, K. (2014). Employees’ adaptability and perceptions of change-related uncertainty: Implications for perceived organizational support, job satisfaction, and performance. Journal of Business and Psychology, 29(2), 269-280.
Kottke, J. L., & Sharafinski, C. E. (1988). Measuring perceived supervisory and organizational support. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 48(4), 1075–1079.

Jonathan H. Westover, PhD is Chief Academic & Learning Officer (HCI Academy); Chair/Professor, Organizational Leadership (UVU); OD Consultant (Human Capital Innovations). Read Jonathan Westover's executive profile here.

Suggested Citation: Westover, J. H. (2025). The Art & Science of Trust. Human Capital Leadership Review, 22(1). doi.org/10.70175/hclreview.2020.22.1.6